YANQ is the peak body for the Queensland Youth Sector
Youth Affairs Network Queensland
  • home
  • about
    • what we do
    • become a member
    • donate
    • our values
    • h*story
  • conference
    • 2014 conference
    • 2011 conference
  • news + resources
    • news from yanq
    • what is youth work?
    • become a youth worker
    • projects >
      • health projects >
        • stop drugging our kids!
        • sexual health
        • youth primary health development
      • youth disability advocacy queensland
      • multicultural youth advocacy network
      • reengagement in education
      • juvenile justice >
        • 17 year olds in adult prisons
        • youth in remand
      • workforce development
    • yanq publications >
      • research papers
      • policy submissions
      • media releases
      • network noise magazine
      • newtransitions journal
  • youth networks
    • yanq regional networks
    • youth interagency details
    • youth consultative network
  • COVID-19 Information for youth services
  • Online Forums
  • contact

Multiculturaliam: From Myth to Reality

12/3/2008

 
By the Youth Affairs Network of Queensland. 

In a global context, recent events around the world and at home necessitate an open public debate on multiculturalism and to form effective strategies for community engagement with this issue. Oft times, even within the Community Services Sector, many organisations are increasingly regarding ‘multiculturalism' as being solely related to issues regarding non-English speaking migrants and refugees. This interpretation and use of ‘multiculturalism' not only denies the role of English speaking migrants, residents and citizens, but also fails to acknowledge the important contributions that Indigenous peoples play in the construction of effective multiculturalism. Indeed, alienating English speakers and Indigenous peoples by denying them a place within concepts of multiculturalism, may serve instead to reinforce the ‘us and them' mentality amongst some members of the wider community, in which the somewhat ignorant ideologies of assimilation and total conformity to mainstream ‘Anglo' culture is a goal.
multiculturalism_-myth_to_reality.pdf
File Size: 101 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Identity is a multifaceted concept, with contributing elements such as nationality, nationhood, indigeneity, ethnicity, religion, ‘race', language and gender playing significant roles. Further contestations arise when people misuse and confuse the terms and implications of ethnicity and nationality. The latter referring - in layman's terms at least - to a person's country of citizenship. When used in this manner, as it is in most state and federal government forms, nationality is a purely political, arguably somewhat arbitrary (though still an important), bureaucratic element of identity. Conversely, and more aligned with its anthropological definition, the term may also relate more closely to nationhood - the state of belonging to a particular group of people from the same ethnic and linguistic family (eg. A person of the American Indian Cherokee nation). This latter use of ‘nation' entwines more closely with ethnicity; a far more prominent facet of identity whether by choice or otherwise of people who are minority group members in a wider society-state. ‘Sense of belonging' incorporates both nationality, and ethnicity, but often, minority group members are forced into relating more intimately with their ethnic identity than their nationality (in this case used as citizenship) when confronted by others who question their right to belong.

The Encarta Concise English Dictionary defines multiculturalism as "relating to, consisting of, or participating in the cultures of different countries, ethnic groups or religions" while online dictionaries define it as "the preservation of different cultures or cultural identities within a unified society, as a state or nation". In view of these definitions, by denying Anglo-Australians in particular a role within multiculturalism, we not only deny that they have culture, but (due to their majority) also simultaneously label them as the base to which all other peoples must conform in order to be ‘Australian'. Similarly, by denying Indigenous peoples a role, we not only deny that they have culture, but fail to recognise their vital role as the first peoples of the land in which we all now live.

The Youth Affairs Network of Queensland (YANQ) is of the view that currently there is an absence of whole-of-society commitment to multiculturalism due to:
  • The existence of a major power imbalance between cultures in Australia;
  • The dominance of the Anglo culture in processes, systems and institutions;
  • Lack of cultural equity, limiting the participation of minority cultures in contributing to policy aims and objectives; and
  • Not acknowledging the culture of the Indigenous people as the basis for multiculturalism in Australia.

Therefore, YANQ believes that the current framework for multiculturalism is heavily ingrained in the structures and processes of the dominant culture, of which non-dominant cultures become subjects of prejudice and discrimination as a result of the unchallenged dominant culture. This inevitably leads to the weakening of the base on which multiculturalism is built upon, as multiculturalism is pursued on existing dominant culture's structures and processes, with the non-dominant cultural groups forced to conform to the so-called "multicultural" framework of the dominant culture. It flows that culturally diverse communities cannot identify with the dominant culture's vision for multiculturalism, becoming distant from the vision itself. Diagram 1.0 is a visual representation of the existing multicultural framework.

If the existing framework's processes and structures continue to perpetuate the dominant culture and are not founded on a strong unified base, there is a potential for disharmony within and across communities, making them vulnerable to prejudice and discrimination.

To move beyond the existing framework for multiculturalism, YANQ firmly believes that the first cultures of Indigenous people must be acknowledged as a basis for multiculturalism, ensuring that the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are recognised for their influential role in laying the foundation for cultural diversity in Australia. These first cultures on which other cultures can be built, provide strength for cultural harmony in Queensland and Australia.

YANQ sees the need for diverse cultural input into the framework for multiculturalism in order to achieve a shared understanding and commitment to multiculturalism in Australia. Diagram 1.1 depicts the proposed framework for multiculturalism.

In the above diagram, the key elements in the proposed framework are:
  • Aboriginal and Torres Strait Island culture as a founding base for multiculturalism
  • Layers of other cultures built upon the base of the first Indigenous culture
  • Processes involving planning, engagement and implementation
  • Structure including systems and institutions are constantly challenged and evolving through diverse cultural input and processes
  • Diverse cultural input from all cultures including Aboriginal and Torres Straight Islander culture, CALD groups, inter-faith groups, Anglo culture and the wider community
  • A shared vision for multiculturalism that is underpinned by processes, structures and diverse community input firmly established on a strong foundation

The proposed framework allows individuals and groups across all cultures in Australia to contribute towards the achievement of multiculturalism through active and continuing engagement in the policy debate.

Ultimately, if multiculturalism is treated as an old politically correct buzz word which has passed its used by date, we will revert back to the assimilation policy. This top down process will allow the dominant culture to maintain its cultural hegemony in Australia.

Alternatively the Non-Government Organisation (NGO) sector can rise up to the challenge by facilitating diverse cultural input into the multicultural framework in order to achieve a shared understanding and commitment to multiculturalism in Australia.

Australia is multi ethnic but remains a mono-culture society, insofar as Anglo Australian culture is continued to be identified simultaneously as ‘without' culture, and as the base to which all others should conform. Multiculturalism is the aspiration of Australian citizens who believe in the strength in our cultural diversity.

Comments are closed.
    Home / Our Work / Our Publications / Research

    Research Papers

    YANQ has spent over two decades at the forefront of youth affairs research in Queensland. This page links to all of our research papers and reports since 1991.

    If you find these resources useful, we encourage you to make a donation below.

    Creative Commons License
    All YANQ publications are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
    POLICY SUBMISSIONS >>
    MEDIA RELEASES >>
    Follow @news_yanq

    Categories

    All
    A.T.S.I.
    Disability
    Education
    Employment
    Engagement
    Homelessness
    Infact
    Juvenile Justice
    Mental Health
    Multiculturalism
    Qld Youth Affairs Conference
    Racism
    Re-engagement
    Remand
    Sexual Health
    Substance Abuse
    Women
    Workforce Development
    Yanq Policy Forum
    Youth Consultative Network
    Youthwork Practice

    Archives

    September 2020
    April 2020
    June 2019
    March 2018
    August 2014
    August 2013
    July 2013
    March 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    January 2012
    August 2011
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    March 2010
    December 2009
    June 2009
    December 2008
    September 2008
    August 2008
    June 2008
    May 2008
    March 2008
    February 2008
    January 2008
    November 2007
    October 2007
    September 2007
    August 2007
    June 2007
    January 2007
    October 2006
    September 2006
    March 2006
    December 2005
    November 2005
    October 2005
    May 2005
    December 2004
    September 2004
    May 2004
    February 2004
    January 2004
    September 2003
    April 2003
    October 2002
    September 2002
    July 2002
    May 2002
    May 2000
    April 2000
    November 1999
    August 1999
    July 1999
    June 1999
    May 1999
    January 1999
    December 1998
    November 1998
    October 1998
    July 1998
    October 1997
    September 1997
    May 1997
    September 1996
    August 1996
    May 1996
    April 1996
    September 1995
    May 1995
    December 1994
    October 1994
    September 1994
    April 1994
    February 1994
    October 1993
    June 1993
    February 1993
    November 1992
    October 1992
    March 1992
    June 1991

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.